Average Distance (km) between location results (November 20 2026)
| IP Provider1 | 51Degrees2 | Digital Element3 | IPinfo4 | MaxMind5 | MaxMind Paid6 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 51Degrees2 | X | X | X | X | X |
| Digital Element3 | N/A | X | X | X | X |
| IPinfo4 | 42 | N/A | X | X | X |
| MaxMind5 | 63 | N/A | 71 | X | X |
| MaxMind Paid6 | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | X |
How was the above IP Intelligence comparison chart created?
Table showing results from a random sample of 50 IPV4 addresses taken on November 20 2026.
51Degrees LocationConfidence is High for all IPV4 addresses used.
Digital Element is not available for public testing. Read more about Digital Element's Netacuity solution.
IPinfo results taken from the IPinfo online tester.
MaxMind results from the publicly available MaxMind online tester.
MaxMind paid is not available for public testing. Read more about MaxMind's Paid offering.
Download the list of IP addresses used for the table IP addresses.
Absent authoritative ground truth, comparing the average distance of results between providers is the best way to observe variations.
Variation between competitors over time
Technical comparison
The table below compares 51Degrees to other leading IP intelligence providers across the measures that matter when choosing a solution. The measures where the providers differ most come first. 51Degrees is the only provider in the table that publishes that it returns the shape of the area as a Well Known Text polygon, weights alternative regions by their share of that area, and randomizes coordinates to guard against tracking individuals. Each competitor fact links to the source it was taken from. Where a provider does not publish a fact, the cell says Unpublished rather than guessing.
| Key metrics | 51Degrees | MaxMind | IPinfo | Digital Element | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Data sources | Registration records of the five Regional Internet Registries7 | Unpublished | ProbeNet internet measurement network8 | More than 20 sources and signals9 | |
| Location granularity | Country, region, town, area polygons, and coordinates10 | Continent, country, subdivisions, city, postal code, and coordinates11 | Country, region, city, postal code, and coordinates12 | Country, region, city, postal code, and sub-postal levels9 | |
| Geospatial results - the shape of the area, not just a point | Yes, a Well Known Text polygon of the area the IP address is likely to be in, with the most likely coordinates inside it10 | No, a point with a circular accuracy radius13 | No, a point with a radius field12 | Unpublished | |
| Weighted results - alternatives when one answer is not certain | Yes, the regions of the location's country, each with its share of the area14 | No, one location per lookup, with a confidence value for each place in the GeoIP Enterprise database and the GeoIP Insights web service15 | No, one location per lookup12 | Unpublished | |
| Location confidence guidance - how far to trust the returned place16 | Yes, bands of High, Medium, Low, or Unknown17 | Yes, percentage confidence values in the GeoIP Enterprise database and the GeoIP Insights web service15 | Unpublished | Unpublished | |
| Accuracy radius - a distance in kilometers from the returned coordinates16 | Yes, AccuracyRadiusMin and AccuracyRadiusMax, the distances from the returned coordinates to the nearest and furthest edges of the area, beside the area itself10 | Yes, accuracy radius in kilometers11 | Yes, radius field in the extended database12 | Unpublished | |
| Coordinate data protection - protection against tracking individuals | Yes, coordinates are moved at random by up to 1 km, and the offset changes once a day10 | Unpublished | Unpublished | Unpublished | |
| Frequency of data updates | Daily, with automatic updates through the SDKs18 | Every weekday for the main GeoIP databases, Tuesdays and Fridays for most free GeoLite databases19 | Daily20 | Weekly for NetAcuity geolocation data9 | |
| Deployment options | On-premise data file and cloud API10 | Downloadable databases and web services API11 | Downloadable databases and API20 | API access, cloud delivery, and file-based formats9 | |
| File format | Binary | MMDB binary and CSV11 | CSV, MMDB, JSON, and Parquet20 | Unpublished | |
| Open-source SDKs | Yes, EUPL 1.221 | Yes, Apache 2.021 | Yes, Apache 2.021 | Unpublished | |
| Free version | Yes, Lite data file with network registration data only22 | Yes, GeoLite with reduced accuracy22 | Yes, IPinfo Lite with country-level location and network data22 | Unpublished | |
| Transparent pricing | Yes for cloud, on request for on-premise23 | Yes11 | Yes23 | Unpublished | |
| ISO certifications | 9001 and 2700124 | None claimed. Security system based on ISO 27001, with a completed SOC 2 Type II audit25 | Unpublished | Unpublished | |
All competitor information accurate as of 18 November 2026 unless otherwise stated. We aim to keep the table up to date. If you see any inaccuracies or outdated information, please email us at marketing@51degrees.com.
51Degrees builds its IP intelligence from the registration records published by the five Regional Internet Registries (AFRINIC, APNIC, ARIN, LACNIC, and RIPE NCC), the bodies that allocate every IP address in use. Registration records state who each block of addresses is allocated to. Some other approaches lean on routing registries, which are separate databases describing how traffic may be routed, and which have documented staleness and forgery problems. See RFC 7682, the RIPE Labs study The IRR Landscape: Data Quality, and the CAIDA paper IRRegularities in the Internet Routing Registry for the evidence.
Source: IPinfo ProbeNet, IPinfo's own internet measurement platform, which IPinfo says "powers every IPinfo product".
Source: Digital Element FAQ, which states over 20 data sources and signals, weekly updates for NetAcuity geolocation data, granularity to sub-postal levels, and deployment through API access, cloud delivery, and file-based formats. The FAQ does not name file formats, a confidence or radius field, a free version, prices, or ISO certifications.
See the IP Intelligence documentation for the properties returned and the on-premise and cloud deployment options, and the Area feature documentation, which describes the area polygons, the most likely coordinates within them, and the AccuracyRadiusMin and AccuracyRadiusMax properties. The area is returned as a Well Known Text vector geometry object. Well Known Text is an open standard for describing shapes, so the returned area can be drawn on a map or used directly in common mapping and database tools. The Randomization documentation and the Latitude and Longitude properties in the property dictionary say that returned coordinates are moved at random by up to 1 km from the original point, for data protection, and that the randomized result changes only once a day.
Source: MaxMind GeoIP Databases page, which lists granularity from continent to approximate coordinates, the accuracy radius in kilometers that MaxMind says must accompany its coordinates, MMDB and CSV formats, weekday updates for the majority of databases, database and web service delivery, and public prices.
Source: IPinfo IP to Geolocation Database (Extended), which lists the fields returned, including a radius field described as "Accuracy radius in terms of kilometers".
Source: MaxMind IP geolocation data knowledge base article, which says the mappable area MaxMind returns "is defined by a circle with its center at a particular latitude and longitude, and an accuracy radius". No polygon or other vector geometry output is described.
See Weighting in the documentation. Where the area an IP address is associated with covers more than one region of its country, StateGeoNameIdsGeographical returns each region's GeoNames id with that region's share of the area.
Source: MaxMind IP geolocation data knowledge base article, which describes confidence factors as MaxMind's "confidence, expressed as a percent, that our geolocation values are correct" for the country, city, subdivisions, and postal code, and lists them in the GeoIP Enterprise database and the GeoIP Insights web service. The web services response documentation describes a single returned location per lookup, with each confidence value from 0 to 100.
A location confidence indicator and an accuracy radius answer different questions, so the table shows them as separate rows. A confidence indicator says how far to trust the returned place, for example whether the town should be relied on at all. An accuracy radius is a distance in kilometers from the returned coordinates. MaxMind describes its accuracy radius as the radius of a circle around the coordinates within which the user is likely to be, and IPinfo describes its radius field as an accuracy radius in kilometers. 51Degrees returns the area itself, and AccuracyRadiusMin and AccuracyRadiusMax give the distances from the coordinates to its nearest and furthest edges. A provider can offer one without the other, and the mechanisms are not interchangeable.
See the 51Degrees LocationConfidence property, which returns High, Medium, Low, or Unknown. High results can be relied upon for all practical purposes, Medium results might be useful where the use case can tolerate a degree of inaccuracy, and Low or Unknown results should be discarded when they might be used to make consequential decisions. Read the location confidence blog post for the measurements behind the bands.
The IP Intelligence quick start lists "Daily automated updates without restarting the process" for on-premise deployment, and the pricing page says data is updated daily on the paid plans. See the automatic data file updates documentation for how the SDKs download a new data file when one is available.
Source: MaxMind GeoIP release notes. The July 2025 note states that the GeoIP City, Country, Enterprise, and ISP databases are updated every weekday, the GeoIP Anonymous databases daily, and the GeoIP Connection Type, GeoIP Domain Name, and most GeoLite databases on Tuesdays and Fridays. The April 2026 note moves the GeoIP Connection Type database to every weekday.
Source: IPinfo IP Database Download page, which lists daily updates and CSV, MMDB, JSON, and Parquet formats alongside the API.
See the SDK source on GitHub for 51Degrees (European Union Public Licence 1.2), MaxMind (Apache 2.0), and IPinfo (Apache 2.0). The license covers the SDK code. The data the SDKs read is licensed separately by each provider.
Free versions differ widely in what they contain. The 51Degrees Lite data file carries RegisteredCountry, RegisteredName, and RegisteredOwner, the registered country, name, and owner of each network, and no town or coordinate data (see the data repository). MaxMind says the free GeoLite City is "considerably less accurate than the paid GeoIP City data". IPinfo Lite carries country-level location and ASN details only. Free versions also differ in how often they update. The 51Degrees free plan's data is updated monthly rather than daily (see the pricing page), and most MaxMind GeoLite databases on Tuesdays and Fridays rather than every weekday (see note 19), while IPinfo says IPinfo Lite is updated daily.
See the 51Degrees pricing page, which lists prices for the cloud plans that include IP intelligence. Paid on-premise data is under the Bespoke plan, which is priced on request. See also the IPinfo pricing page.
51Degrees is certified to ISO 9001 for quality management and ISO/IEC 27001 for information security management. Read more about how and why we embraced ISO.
Source: MaxMind Commitment to Security, which states an information security management system "based on the ISO 27001 standard" and a completed SOC 2 Type II audit. MaxMind does not claim ISO certification itself, so the cell records the audit and the standard its system is based on rather than a certification.
The tables show the same providers as the accuracy comparison above, and other providers exist. DB-IP offers commercial databases with daily updates in CSV and MMDB formats and a free Lite edition updated monthly, and IP2Location offers downloadable databases in 26 packages and a free IP2Location LITE database.
Country results compared
The country is the answer most businesses act on first, whether that is the currency to show or the content a license allows. The table below compares what each provider publishes for country results. Each competitor fact links to the source it was taken from. Where a provider does not publish a fact, the cell says Unpublished rather than guessing.
| Country results | 51Degrees | MaxMind | IPinfo | Digital Element | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| How certain the country is | Yes, the LocationConfidence bands for the place as a whole17 | Yes, a country confidence value in the GeoIP Enterprise database and the GeoIP Insights web service, which the GeoIP City and Country databases do not carry1526 | No confidence or probability for the country in the published schema27 | Unpublished28 | |
| Country the network is registered in, as well as the country the address is used in | Yes, RegisteredCountry29 | Yes, a registered country field30 | No registered country field in the published schema27 | Unpublished28 | |
All competitor information accurate as of 18 November 2026 unless otherwise stated. We aim to keep the table up to date. If you see any inaccuracies or outdated information, please email us at marketing@51degrees.com.
Source: MaxMind GeoIP City and Country Databases, whose documented fields include the accuracy radius but no confidence value. Of MaxMind's downloadable databases, the GeoIP Enterprise database carries the confidence values (see note 15).
Source: IPinfo IP to Geolocation Database, which lists a single country and country_code field for each network, with no registered country field and no confidence or probability value.
The Digital Element FAQ cited in note 9 publishes granularity and update frequency, and states coverage of virtually all countries and regions worldwide, but does not describe a country confidence value. NetAcuity is not available for public testing, so these cells record what is published rather than what is returned.
See Countries in the documentation, which says "RegisteredCountry is the code of the country the IP address range is registered in", separately from the country the location is in.
Source: the MaxMind web services response documentation already cited in note 15, which shows one country object per response, and separate registered country and represented country objects for the country where the ISP registered the IP address and for cases such as an overseas military base. The registered and represented country objects describe different relationships to the same address rather than alternative answers to the same question.
The accuracy table at the top of this page measures coordinates rather than countries, because a distance can be compared between providers without anybody's ground truth. Country accuracy percentages are published by providers against their own private test sets, so they cannot be compared on the same basis and are not repeated here. What can be compared is what each provider returns for a country, which is what the table above does.
For a property by property mapping against each provider, see From MaxMind and From IPinfo in the documentation.
